Who's more overrated??

They're not that overrated. Verlander is a top five pitcher in the AL and possibly the whole MLB, he provides just what the Tigers need, and btw, I don't think Verlander would be placed 4th in the Phillies rotation, he would be 2nd or 3rd at least. As for Miguel Cabrera, he isnt much of an overrated player since first basemens like Adrian Gonzales, Prince Feilder and etc. are having a better season than he is.